I went to watch her video to understand... Lol. I definitely think it's weird to reread all the books, from Harry Potter to Devils advocate.... Maybe I'm mistaken, but people usually read a book and move on to the next one and only go back to really outstanding favourites/interesting pieces? Maybe she just didn't understand the books first time? Hard to say...Kattiness Everdeen wrote: ↑Fri Apr 26, 2019 9:21 amI was wondering if Shari thinking LOTR's was too deep/complex for her to grasp at 15 was an indication of her true intelligence.....looks like it might be. Maybe she has the same problem as Abby, where she is obsessed with reading, but she doesn't seem to be grasping the material, or picking up the vocabulary & grammar? That would explain why her book list is so strange and disjointed. She didn't convince me to read any of them; I don't ever want to read Dumas now! It seems like several books only made it on the list, because they were deemed "a literary classic" at school, and she could somewhat tolerate them. She gave off the impression that she likes romance novels and fantasy, although reading love scenes out to her brother in front of her grandparents seems a little twisted. It also appears she doesn't know the definition of a novel.lightasfeather wrote: ↑Fri Apr 26, 2019 6:52 amFrom what I've heard people complain about book's pace mostly and it going too slow, especially for younger audience. So they get bored and abandon the book... Which is often the case with classical literature too but there the complexity is often to blame, while here not really.lightasfeather wrote: ↑Fri Apr 26, 2019 6:45 am
Not really hard to read - just long and often don't hold younger reader's attention. But they are very straightforward, with no deep metaphors or complicated psychological development. I checked and based on their Lexile rating they are suitable for good reader in 5th grade (10yrs) or poor reader in 9th grade (14 yrs). The only problem is to find a ten year old who is interested in the story, but language/grammar/etc. are pretty simple.
Did anyone else think it is weird that she called her English teacher her "2nd father"? There seems to be a pattern emerging of Shari seeking out inappropriate relationships with older men in authority Dr. Coach anyone?
It's also weird to include books for young children in your "favourite books" list at 16 - maybe I'm overthinking it but I would guess that she might not have read as many books as she wants ppl to believe when those books she read like 8-9 yes ago still make it to the list (with notion she may not really like them - but it's great book... Almost as if it was complete list of what she read, not favourites).
The Count of Monte Christo is great book for young teens (or children if they read adjusted version), but she didn't really get what it was about right... When quoting from Dracula her diction made the excerpt incomprehensible, but made it clear she didn't know what she was reading. Combine that with comments on book cover and black outline of pages and there is a good reason to doubt she understood it. But maybe I'm just being harsh... At least she used to read, that's a positive in any case.